Prior to Ohio State
- A two-sport athlete who played football and lacrosse for Lutheran.
- Team captain and all-county selection on the lacrosse field.
- The NYSAIS points leader for attackmen.
- Served as team captain in football where he was an all-county choice while leading his team in interceptions.
- Was on the winning team in the World Series of Youth Lacrosse Championship in Mile High Stadium in Denver in October of 2017.
- Has a brother, Brendan, who was an All-American lacrosse player at Brown and played in the Final Four.
- Is the son of George and Mary Jean Caputo.